The “Relic” Guitar Trend: Does It Add Value or Is It Just Artificial Wear?

Guitar enthusiasts worldwide continuously search for instruments that fit their unique needs and aesthetics. One particular trend that has grown over the past few years is the preference for “relic” or “aged” guitars. These instruments show signs of wear and tear, such as scratches, dents, and worn-out finishes, despite being relatively new. But does this relic treatment add genuine value to the guitar, or is it merely a cosmetic change? Let’s explore both sides of the debate.

Fender Road Worn 50s relic Stratocaster.
Photo by irish10567, Photo under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license

History of the Relic Trend

Vintage instruments are not just tools for producing music; they are artifacts with stories etched into their very being. Every scratch, dent, or worn-out patch bears witness to the changing tides of music history, and the hands of countless musicians who’ve wielded these instruments as an extension of their soul.

The Golden Era of Guitars

The 1950s and 1960s, often referred to as the “Golden Era” of guitar manufacturing, saw the birth of many guitar models that are now considered classics. Brands like Fender, Gibson, and Gretsch released instruments that would go on to shape the sound of rock ‘n’ roll, blues, and jazz. Musicians of the time, from Jimi Hendrix to Eric Clapton, championed these instruments, embedding them in the fabric of music history. As these guitars aged, they bore the scars of countless gigs, jam sessions, and tours, acquiring a character that new, off-the-shelf models seemed to lack.

The Tone Debate

The discussion surrounding the superior tonal qualities of vintage guitars versus newer models has been ongoing for decades. Some of this is undoubtedly subjective, as tone can be a deeply personal preference. However, there are facts to consider. For example, the wood used in older guitars often came from trees that had grown slower, resulting in denser wood grain patterns, which many believe contributed to a richer, fuller sound.

Furthermore, as wood ages, it dries out and resonates differently. The molecular changes in the wood, combined with the natural oxidation of electronics and hardware, can produce a tone that’s distinct from newer instruments. This aging process is often cited as the reason vintage guitars offer a warmth and resonance that is hard to replicate in new models.

The Shift in Manufacturing

Another pivotal point to consider is the shift in manufacturing processes. In the past, guitars were often handcrafted, with individual attention given to every detail. As demand grew, many manufacturers transitioned to mass production techniques, which, while efficient, could sometimes result in subtle differences in quality and character. This transition further elevated the status of guitars produced during the handcrafted era, enhancing their allure.

The Birth of Relic’ing

As the 20th century drew to a close, musicians and collectors began to realize the finite nature of these vintage instruments. As prices soared and genuine vintage guitars became increasingly hard to find, a gap emerged in the market. Guitarists wanted the vintage look and feel but either couldn’t afford or find an authentic vintage piece. Recognizing this, manufacturers began to introduce “relic” or “aged” versions of their popular models, aiming to recapture the aesthetics, and in some cases, the tonal qualities of those revered vintage guitars.

In conclusion, the relic trend finds its roots not just in the aesthetic appeal of vintage guitars but also in their storied history, the evolution of guitar manufacturing, and the ever-evolving debate around tone. As with many elements of music and art, this trend is a testament to the ongoing dialogue between the past and the present.

Pros of Relic Guitars

Aesthetics and Personality

Many players believe that a relic’d guitar carries a certain charm or character. These guitars instantly provide a lived-in look, allowing musicians to feel as if they’re holding a piece of history in their hands.

Playability

Some argue that relic treatments, especially on the neck, can enhance the guitar’s playability. By simulating the natural wear of decades of playing, the guitar might feel smoother and more comfortable in the hands of the musician.

Immediate Vintage Vibe

For guitarists who want to capture the vibe of vintage instruments in their performances without actually purchasing a vintage piece, relic guitars can be an attractive option. They can provide the look and, in some cases, the feel of an older guitar without the vintage price tag.

Cons of Relic Guitars

Authenticity Concerns

Some purists argue that the wear on a guitar should represent the journey of the musician who owns it. For them, artificially aging a guitar might feel inauthentic, as the wear and tear haven’t been earned through years of playing.

Price Implications

Relic treatments can often raise the price of a guitar. Some consumers argue that this increase doesn’t necessarily equate to an improvement in sound quality or functionality, making the additional cost hard to justify for everyone.

Durability Questions

There are concerns about whether or not the relic process might compromise the guitar’s long-term durability. By introducing intentional imperfections, are manufacturers inadvertently weakening the instrument?

The Impact on Value

Monetary Value

From a monetary perspective, relic guitars often command higher prices than their non-relic counterparts from the same manufacturer. This is due to the additional labor and craftsmanship required to age the guitar. However, it’s worth noting that a relic’d guitar’s resale value might not necessarily be higher than a non-relic model, especially if the relic’ing isn’t done by the original manufacturer.

Emotional and Artistic Value

Value can also be subjective and emotional. For many musicians, the instrument’s look and feel can have a profound impact on their creativity and connection with the guitar. If a relic’d guitar inspires a musician and feels right in their hands, its value might be immeasurable.

Functional Value

If a relic treatment genuinely improves playability, it can add functional value to the guitar. However, if the relic’ing is purely cosmetic and doesn’t enhance the instrument’s feel or playability, some might argue that its functional value remains unchanged.

In Conclusion

Like many trends in the music industry, the value and appeal of relic guitars are subjective. While some see them as inauthentic reproductions, others view them as works of art, blending modern craftsmanship with vintage aesthetics.

In determining the value of a relic guitar, potential buyers should consider their personal preferences, playing needs, and budget. Whether or not a relic’d guitar is worth the investment will ultimately depend on the individual musician’s perspective.

Similar Posts